Sergio Leone Web Board

Other/Miscellaneous => Off-Topic Discussion => Topic started by: titoli on September 23, 2011, 12:29:18 PM



Title: The Amazing Mr X - a.k.a. The Spiritualist (1948)
Post by: titoli on September 23, 2011, 12:29:18 PM
It is roughly divided in 3 parts (first a supernatural one, or so it seems. Then there's the activity of the spiritualist to come under the eye and everything seems to find a rational explanation. And then there's...well, I won't spoil it) and, until the last 15 minutes, you don't know where it's at: which makes  good entertaining. People praise Alton's photography: yes, but photography never fares well on its own. The actors are mostly unknown (apart from O'Donnell) but are decent. Is this a noir. Not, as usual, for me. But it must be noted that in USA this was commercialized on dvd (according to a IMDB reviewer, in a cheap SF collection of 50 titles. I bought the french release.

(http://img.filmsactu.net/datas/dvd/l/i/l-incroyable-m-x/v/473831413cfd1.jpg)

7\10


Title: Re: The Amazing Mr X - a.k.a. The Spiritualist (1948)
Post by: dave jenkins on September 23, 2011, 01:37:07 PM
It is roughly divided in 3 parts (first a supernatural one, or so it seems. Then there's the activity of the spiritualist to come under the eye and everything seems to find a rational explanation. And then there's...well, I won't spoil it) and, until the last 15 minutes, you don't know where it's at: which makes  good entertaining. People praise Alton's photography: yes, but photography never fares well on its own. The actors are mostly unknown (apart from O'Donnell) but are decent. Is this a noir. Not, as usual, for me. But it must be noted that in USA this was commercialized on dvd (according to a IMDB reviewer, in a cheap SF collection of 50 titles. I bought the french release.

(http://img.filmsactu.net/datas/dvd/l/i/l-incroyable-m-x/v/473831413cfd1.jpg)

7\10
Well, Lynn Bari isn't a complete unknown, I've seen her in a few things. I like her a lot: good-looking AND good-sounding--I could listen to her voice for hours.

I like the film a lot too. I'd be more inclined to give it an "8."


Title: Re: The Amazing Mr X - a.k.a. The Spiritualist (1948)
Post by: cigar joe on September 23, 2011, 02:59:22 PM
It is roughly divided in 3 parts (first a supernatural one, or so it seems. Then there's the activity of the spiritualist to come under the eye and everything seems to find a rational explanation. And then there's...well, I won't spoil it) and, until the last 15 minutes, you don't know where it's at: which makes  good entertaining. People praise Alton's photography: yes, but photography never fares well on its own. The actors are mostly unknown (apart from O'Donnell) but are decent. Is this a noir. Not, as usual, for me. But it must be noted that in USA this was commercialized on dvd (according to a IMDB reviewer, in a cheap SF collection of 50 titles. I bought the french release.

(http://img.filmsactu.net/datas/dvd/l/i/l-incroyable-m-x/v/473831413cfd1.jpg)

7\10

Never heard of this one


Title: Re: The Amazing Mr X - a.k.a. The Spiritualist (1948)
Post by: titoli on September 23, 2011, 03:08:10 PM
Well, Lynn Bari isn't a complete unknown, I've seen her in a few things. I like her a lot: good-looking AND good-sounding--I could listen to her voice for hours.

A poor man's Ava Gardner.

Quote
I like the film a lot too. I'd be more inclined to give it an "8."

That's what I could have given it had it not been for the finale which looks rather pasted up and uninventive. I think they should have played more on the supernatural|rational opposition leaving the audience in doubt as to the explanation.


Title: Re: The Amazing Mr X - a.k.a. The Spiritualist (1948)
Post by: dave jenkins on September 23, 2011, 11:38:17 PM
That's what I could have given it had it not been for the finale which looks rather pasted up and uninventive. I think they should have played more on the supernatural|rational opposition leaving the audience in doubt as to the explanation.
For that I would go "10."


Title: Re: The Amazing Mr X - a.k.a. The Spiritualist (1948)
Post by: Novecento on September 24, 2011, 05:54:21 AM
People praise Alton's photography: yes, but photography never fares well on its own.

Actually when it comes to noirs, that's a big selling point for me. Never seen this one personally, but John Alton's name makes me want to watch it regardless.


Title: Re: The Amazing Mr X - a.k.a. The Spiritualist (1948)
Post by: cigar joe on October 13, 2011, 09:21:27 PM
The Amazing Mr. X (The Spiratulist) (1948).Director: Bernard Vorhaus.
With Turhan Bey, Lynn Bari, Cathy O'Donnell, Richard Carlson, Donald Curtis, and Virginia Gregg.
The story is a very rich widow Christine Faber (Bari), walking on the beach one night, thinks she hears her late husband Paul calling out of the surf. She then is surprised by Alexis (Bey) a spiritualist, who seems to know all about her past. After participating in some seances, Christine and younger sister Janet become infatuated with Alexis; but he in an interesting twist in turn finds himself manipulated.

Its sort of a high society melodrama Noir, that lacks the gritty, sleazy, underworld characters that I favor in Film Noir. Its entertaining with some nice cinematography.  7/10.