Sergio Leone Web Board

Films of Sergio Leone => Other Films => Topic started by: titoli on September 20, 2012, 02:42:27 PM



Title: Kansas Raiders (1950)
Post by: titoli on September 20, 2012, 02:42:27 PM
Unexpectedly good movie about the (not yet) James' gang time with Quantrill. Garfield dubs it as "dated", though admitting it has some good elements. I disagree (and see that most people at IMDB agree with me) in that it was unusual for the time (and even later) to present Quantrill as a criminal with a touch of Roy Beannessitude about him but still never losing his dignity (thanx to the usual great Donlevy's performance). I don't care about the messing up with history: the movie is enjoyable from start to end and it earns 8\10.


Title: Kansas Raiders (1950)
Post by: Spikeopath on May 09, 2017, 05:24:30 AM
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0042629/reference

More recruits for the butcher brigade.

Kansas Raiders is directed by Ray Enright and written by Robert Richards. It stars Audie Murphy, Brian Donlevy, Marguerite Chapman, Scott Brady and Tony Curtis. A Technicolor production, music is by Milton Rosen and cinematography by Irving Glassberg. Plot has it that the James and Younger Brothers along with Kit Dalton, join Quantrill's Raiders after witnessing at first hand Redleg atrocities. However, after believing they would be fighting soldiers for the war effort, the men find themselves participating in equally worse war crimes. Something that deeply affects the young Jesse James.

OK, it's very fanciful in its telling of a bitter and sad period of American history. Facts of the period and the characters are jettisoned in favour of making an exciting 1950 Oater. Any hope of a depth strewn historical take on William Quantrill's Raiders will lead to disappointment, something that is all too evident with many of the venomous reviews of the film out in internet world. Yet judged on its own unfussy entertaining terms, film scores high for the casual Western fan as shoot-outs, knife fights and stand-offs keep the film perky.

The ominous black flag of Quantrill.

As a story the film provides enough of an edge to make its point, we are left in no doubt about the "atrocity exhibition" dealt out by Quantrill's Raiders. There's also a neat thread within about the corruption of youth. Yes, for sure it's a picture low on accuracy, but it doesn't soft soap the subject to hand. This is a 1950 production after all and the makers at least manage to leave us in no doubt about the nature of the crimes committed by certain factions in the Civil War. In fact a couple of scenes really leave indelible images, and from an action viewpoint the "sacking of Lawrence" is excellent in construction and impact garnered.

Production wise it's also good value, Glassberg's Technicolor photography is gorgeous, not just for the Garner Valley and Kanab locations, but also for bringing out the quality of the set decoration (Russell A. Gausman/Ruby R. Levitt) and Bill Thomas' costuming. Cast are fine without pulling up any trees. Donlevy is the class act on show, but here as Quantrill he gets by on presence alone, the absence of outright character nastiness is sadly felt. The latter of which, however, is provided by the solid Brady as Bill Anderson. Murphy as young Jesse James has youthful exuberance and bravado down pat, while Curtis as Kit Dalton is enjoyable in amongst the five group dynamic. Marguerite Chapman (Coroner Creek) as Kate Clarke (Quantrill's girl) has the tough task of playing the sole female in the film, and although well older than the character in real life, she does a nice line in sexy and wise older woman for the scenes shared with Murphy's James. 7/10

UK cable viewing.


Title: Re: Kansas Raiders (1950)
Post by: stanton on May 09, 2017, 05:58:20 AM
Mediocre western with a bad end. The first half created a few expectations, which the boring 2nd half then completely ruins. 2/10


Title: Re: Kansas Raiders (1950)
Post by: Spikeopath on May 09, 2017, 07:40:02 AM
Unexpectedly good movie about the (not yet) James' gang time with Quantrill. Garfield dubs it as "dated", though admitting it has some good elements. I disagree (and see that most people at IMDB agree with me) in that it was unusual for the time (and even later) to present Quantrill as a criminal with a touch of Roy Beannessitude about him but still never losing his dignity (thanx to the usual great Donlevy's performance). I don't care about the messing up with history: the movie is enjoyable from start to end and it earns 8\10.

BRAVO!

Not Indexed mate.


Title: Re: Kansas Raiders (1950)
Post by: cigar joe on May 09, 2017, 08:20:45 PM
fixed and indexed O0