Sergio Leone Web Board

Films of Sergio Leone => Other Films => Topic started by: Marco Leone on May 02, 2005, 04:03:50 PM



Title: Hate Thy Neighbour
Post by: Marco Leone on May 02, 2005, 04:03:50 PM
Well got my DVD player working again, so back to writing reviews for my web site!  Here is my effort for the Baldi film "Hate Thy Neighbour" :

"Hate Thy Neighbour" combines the classic Spaghetti revenge scenario, with the regular Spaghetti "map" tale. The story centres around Ken Dakota's search for the murderer of his brother, who was killed by bandit Gary Stevens, at the behest of Mexican land owner Chris Malone, for a goldmine map. Stevens tears the map in two, and gives Malone half, spiralling into a running feud of double crosses between the two, whilst Dakota attempts to bring the men responsible for his brothers death to justice.

This is a really enjoyable Spaghetti Western, albeit with the odd moment of corny dialogue. It includes some really exciting moments, such as peasants and bandits duelling with metal claws for Malone's pleasure, torture by hanging over a pit of snakes, and some very talented bandito musicianship! My experiences to date have highlighted that Director Baldi can come up with some great movies (Blindman, Viva Django) and some absolute turkeys (Get Mean and, so I've heard, Rita of the West). Hate Thy Neighbour doesn't hit the highs of Blindman by any means, but is certainly an enjoyable view, with George Eastman (as Stevens) and Horst Frank (Malone) putting in good roles, and the plot having some quality twists and turns.

Not the easiest of movies to get your hands on, but certainly worth the effort if you are a fan of the Spaghetti genre.

p.s. Feel free to send me any Spaghetti Western reviews to post on my site.  It is slowly but surely expanding!  The link should hopefully be below!


Title: Hate Thy Neighbour (Odia il prossimo tuo)(1968)
Post by: titoli on January 20, 2007, 01:14:08 AM
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0189844/

http://www.spaghettiwestern.altervista.org/vari-west29.htm


I caught this on a local station by chance, missed the beginning, and first thought was that the movie had a good rhythm, though I didn't know that the director was the same as Django Kills, another movie based on narrative rhythm. There's a plot twist every 5 minutes, usually without any logical foundation, but who cares? Also, there's a high degree of violence, sadism, some good looking woman (anybody cares that Nicoletta Machiavelli can't play? I'd rather see her on a screen than Bette Davis), some original, though essentially demential, inventions like the "hook" gladatorial fights. Main problem is the hero: Focas just ain't up to  Frank (perfect as usual in his classic role of villain) and Eastman (who can't play for life but has a decent screen presence) and in the end he comes up like a third, unnecesary element in the basic fight of Eastman against Frank. Score merely functional. 


Title: Re: Hate Thy Neighbour (Odia il prossimo tuo)(1968)
Post by: The Firecracker on January 20, 2007, 01:18:12 AM
Been dying to see this one. I'll watch it tomorrow and let you know what I thought.


Title: Re: Hate Thy Neighbour (Odia il prossimo tuo)(1968)
Post by: titoli on January 20, 2007, 01:44:11 AM
You said the same about a Fidani. And I'm still waiting.


Title: Re: Hate Thy Neighbour (Odia il prossimo tuo)(1968)
Post by: The Firecracker on January 20, 2007, 01:51:37 AM
You said the same about a Fidani. And I'm still waiting.


work work work.


Title: Re: Hate Thy Neighbour (Odia il prossimo tuo)(1968)
Post by: titoli on January 20, 2007, 03:55:46 AM
then, don't make promises but to yourself. (this would make a great title for a Fidani).


Title: Re: Hate Thy Neighbour (Odia il prossimo tuo)(1968)
Post by: Banjo on January 20, 2007, 09:12:00 AM
Been dying to see this one. I'll watch it tomorrow and let you know what I thought.
I'm gonna do the same.Thanks Titoli for bringing this up.


Title: Re: Hate Thy Neighbour (Odia il prossimo tuo)(1968)
Post by: Banjo on January 22, 2007, 01:15:40 AM
   Yes it was watchably above average.Frank as always is brilliant as the main bad guy and i enjoyed the gladiator/russian roulette game of death but  why couldn't Ferdinando Baldi(btw Questi directed Django Kill ) have brought in Franco Nero or Terence Hill in as the hero was mediocre?I also thought the ending was an anti-climax due mainly to a lack of a proper face to face gun duel.The (only OK)music by Anton Abril is very similar to what he did for Baldi's Texas Adios.
I give it 7 out of 10 O0


Title: Re: Hate Thy Neighbour (Odia il prossimo tuo)(1968)
Post by: titoli on January 22, 2007, 04:08:59 AM
Of course he wouldn't have no Hill or Nero because of money or because they were busy.

I meant Viva Django, not Django Kills, sorry. I concur on 7/10.


Title: Re: Hate Thy Neighbour (Odia il prossimo tuo)(1968)
Post by: Marco Leone on January 22, 2007, 07:17:36 AM
Its been a while since I watched this, but I know I enjoyed it at the time.  I always have alot of time for George Eastman and Horst Frank.  Particular highlight was the dual with metal claws, and the torture over the pit of snakes.  I gave it a 3/4 rating which is a "recommended" by my reckoning!   O0


Title: Re: Hate Thy Neighbour (Odia il prossimo tuo)(1968)
Post by: The Firecracker on January 23, 2007, 05:43:53 AM
   Yes it was watchably above average.Frank as always is brilliant as the main bad guy and i enjoyed the gladiator/russian roulette game of death but  why couldn't Ferdinando Baldi(btw Questi directed Django Kill ) have brought in Franco Nero or Terence Hill in as the hero was mediocre?I also thought the ending was an anti-climax due mainly to a lack of a proper face to face gun duel.The (only OK)music by Anton Abril is very similar to what he did for Baldi's Texas Adios.
I give it 7 out of 10 O0


I enjoyed this muchly.

good use of editing during fist and gunfights.

Like Banjo I thought the end was an anti-climax as well. Horst should have been killed in the pit of snakes or something.
The gladitor arena is what was needed in the odd-ball western "Death Walks in Laredo" to go with the villains fetish for Julius Cesar.
The score is crap. Abril did a better job with "Texas Adios".


The hero is virtually non-existant in this. Much rather would have seen more Eastman.

80%


Title: Re: Hate Thy Neighbour (Odia il prossimo tuo)(1968)
Post by: Banjo on January 23, 2007, 07:58:28 AM
I always have alot of time for George Eastman
I'd say he's nothing special,and i had to look him up in Weissers book to remind me what else i've seen him in.I suppose he was ok in Ben and Charlie if they couldn't have found someone else as a foil for Guiliana Gemma.
   I'm really becoming a huge fan of Horst Frank who never disappoints as a bad guy(can't imagine him as the hero) so i must make a point of watching Winnetou The Warrior which i've been putting off.


Title: Re: Hate Thy Neighbour (Odia il prossimo tuo)(1968)
Post by: The Firecracker on January 23, 2007, 12:55:19 PM
so i must make a point of watching Winnetou The Warrior which i've been putting off.


Those Winnetou films don't really look all that appealing.


I think "Hate Thy Neighbor" just might be Baldi's best. I find it much more re-wacthable than "Texas adios" or that snoozefest "The Forgotten pistolero" (Have to give this a proper 2nd viewing). And I think the plot holds up better (and the action is much more consistant)than "Blindman" or "Get Mean".



Title: Re: Hate Thy Neighbour (Odia il prossimo tuo)(1968)
Post by: Arizona Colt on January 23, 2007, 02:04:34 PM
Anton Garcia Abril is probably most famous in the US for his supremely creepy and scary soundtrack for LA NOCHE DEL TERROR CIEGO aka TOMBS OF THE BLIND DEAD and its three sequels. That is one score that cries out for a CD release.

George Eastman aka Luigi Montefiore is remembered more for being a screen presence. He really defines menace in ANTHROPOPHAGUS (1980) and also stands out in Martino's 2019: AFTER THE FALL OF NEW YORK (1983) playing Big Ape and in Castellari's 1990: THE BRONX WARRIORS as Golem (I think). He also contributes to the writing of nearly every movie he appears in.


Title: Re: Hate Thy Neighbour (Odia il prossimo tuo)(1968)
Post by: The Firecracker on January 23, 2007, 02:36:50 PM
Anton Garcia Abril is probably most famous in the US for his supremely creepy and scary soundtrack for LA NOCHE DEL TERROR CIEGO aka TOMBS OF THE BLIND DEAD and its three sequels.




They have those on sale at wal mart! It comes in a nice coffin set. Is it worth 70 dollars though?


Title: Re: Hate Thy Neighbour (Odia il prossimo tuo)(1968)
Post by: Arizona Colt on January 23, 2007, 02:44:13 PM
I'm referring to the soundtrack. I bought my BLIND DEAD box for $60.00 from xploited. It's higher everywhere else though.


Title: Re: Hate Thy Neighbour (Odia il prossimo tuo)(1968)
Post by: Banjo on January 24, 2007, 05:29:52 AM

Those Winnetou films don't really look all that appealing.


I think "Hate Thy Neighbor" just might be Baldi's best. I find it much more re-wacthable than "Texas adios" or that snoozefest "The Forgotten pistolero" (Have to give this a proper 2nd viewing). And I think the plot holds up better (and the action is much more consistant)than "Blindman" or "Get Mean".


I made a mistake with Horst Frank who in fact starred in Winnetou:Last Of The Renegades  :-[

Blindman has to be the most original and best Baldi sw,followed by Viva Django,Forgotten Pistolero,Texas Adios and then Hate Thy Neighbour.
I only watched about 10 minutes of Get Mean which i absolutely hated and unfortunately Coming At Ya is unwatchable but this may be due to the wrong 3d glasses.
I'd be interested in catching either of the Carambola(Trinity rip offs) films and i'm sure Horst Frank is involved in one of these too.Not sure i'll ever try and get hold of Rita Of The West! :-\


Title: Re: Hate Thy Neighbour (Odia il prossimo tuo)(1968)
Post by: Marco Leone on January 24, 2007, 07:31:00 AM
I agree on Get Mean, Banjo.  I can't fathom the thinking on why Baldi/Anthony made that one.  Barely watchable as a SW!

I do love Forgotten Pistolero though - a particular favourite of mine.  It gets the 4 star treatment from me!


Title: Re: Hate Thy Neighbour (Odia il prossimo tuo)(1968)
Post by: Arizona Colt on January 24, 2007, 10:18:11 AM
Ditto for FORGOTTEN PISTOLERO! And you shouldn't bother with RITA OF THE WEST unless you can find it free or a few dollars. It has "For domestic release only" written all over it. There are a couple of nice bits but not enough to recommend it. Even Terence Hill appears embarassed in his scenes as he doesn't participate in any singin' and dancin'.


Title: Re: Hate Thy Neighbour (Odia il prossimo tuo)(1968)
Post by: The Firecracker on January 24, 2007, 11:20:46 AM
I agree on Get Mean, Banjo.  I can't fathom the thinking on why Baldi/Anthony made that one.  Barely watchable as a SW!


But watchable as a trashy art flick.


Title: Re: Hate Thy Neighbour (Odia il prossimo tuo)(1968)
Post by: Banjo on January 24, 2007, 04:59:47 PM
I agree on Get Mean, Banjo.  I can't fathom the thinking on why Baldi/Anthony made that one.  Barely watchable as a SW!
I got through it but i found Silent Stranger barely watchable.I'm surprised at how much coverage the Stranger series gets because in all honesty the only decent one is the Stranger Returns.


Title: Re: Hate Thy Neighbour (Odia il prossimo tuo)(1968)
Post by: The Firecracker on January 24, 2007, 11:17:23 PM
I got through it but i found Silent Stranger barely watchable.I'm surprised at how much coverage the Stranger series gets because in all honesty the only decent one is the Stranger Returns.

The coverage might have something to do with the popularity the first two films got in the U.S.



Title: Re: Hate Thy Neighbour (Odia il prossimo tuo)(1968)
Post by: Marco Leone on January 25, 2007, 07:24:06 AM
I got through it but i found Silent Stranger barely watchable.I'm surprised at how much coverage the Stranger series gets because in all honesty the only decent one is the Stranger Returns.

I may be wrong, but I think The Silent Stranger is Tony Anthony's particular favourite.  It has its merits, but is nowhere near The Stranger Returns quality.  I much prefer it to Get Mean though.


Title: Re: Hate Thy Neighbour (Odia il prossimo tuo)(1968)
Post by: The Firecracker on January 25, 2007, 09:43:06 AM
I may be wrong, but I think The Silent Stranger is Tony Anthony's particular favourite.



Yeah he said it was the best film he had ever done but the studios cut a big chunk of it so when it was released ten years after it was finished it was "watered down to nothing".


Title: Re: Hate Thy Neighbour (Odia il prossimo tuo)(1968)
Post by: The Firecracker on June 18, 2007, 09:32:54 PM
This is being released  by wild east in a George Eastman double feature.

(http://www.wildeast.net/hate%20front.jpg)



Release date has yet to be specified.




Title: Re: Hate Thy Neighbour
Post by: Arizona Colt on June 19, 2007, 05:23:57 AM
I got HATE THY NEIGHBOR in a trade. Haven't watched it yet. The opening credits sequence is very creative. Banjo, you've viewed it already, right?


Title: Re: Hate Thy Neighbour
Post by: The Firecracker on June 19, 2007, 10:59:10 AM
I got HATE THY NEIGHBOR in a trade. Haven't watched it yet. The opening credits sequence is very creative. Banjo, you've viewed it already, right?


I'm a fan of it.
Give it about 10 minutes for it to really get going.
Lot's of fun action, kinky torture and a good fist fight.
Ending is an anti-climax but that can be forgiven.