M (1951)

[cigar joe]

Directed by Joseph Losey. Starring quite the cast of Noir players, David Wayne, Howard Da Silva (They Drive By Night), Glenn Anders (The Lady From Shanghai)Luther Adler (Kiss Tomorrow Goodbye, D.O.A., House of Strangers), Raymond Burr(Raw Deal, Sleep My Love, Red Light), Jim Backus, and Martin Gabel. Able to watch a DVDr of this today and though I wasn't expecting much was actually impressed with what I saw even though the transfer was decent. I've seen the original a while back and have since picked up the Hardback Graphic Novel by Jon J. Muth at a used bookstore, and pretty much concur with what this poster on IMDb posted:

Very Good Film Indeed!, 22 January 2007

Author: kirksworks from Marin County, California
*** This review may contain spoilers ***

This is a wrongly maligned film. Fritz Lang, director of the original version, famously hated Joseph Losey's remake, but that is no reason to brush if off. Even if the remake of "M" were poorly directed and acted, the film has so much value as an historic document of old Los Angeles, it is a crime it is unavailable for the general public on video in any format.

Yet, the film has far more than its historic legacy. Losey's "M" is not the masterpiece that Lang's original is, but it's sure a darn great film, with fine performances by David Wayne as the killer, Howard De Silva as the head of the investigation, and Luther Adler as the drunken crime boss lawyer. I must also add that there are a number of changes to Lang's film. In one regard, the remake is simplified, with less delineated individual characters and an overall faster pace. This actually streamlines the action somewhat, while losing the strength of Lang's depth of minor characters. In other ways, the film expands on the original.

(MAJOR SPOILERS AHEAD!) While it has shortchanged some of the minor characters, Losey's film has developed the crime boss beyond Lang's film, and is more explicit in revealing the man's violent nature, particularly in the closing moments when he he shoots his lawyer just as the police arrive. There's a fine irony as a result of at least one change. Another reviewer pointed out that the children in the film would hardly have gone off with the murderer as easily as they did, however, they do so in the original version as well. What is interesting in Losey's film is that both the murderer and a little girl (his intended victim) get trapped in the Bradbury building at the film's climax. It is the crime syndicate (not the police) that finally rescue her and as they carry her away (to take her back home) the girl finally asks, "Where are you taking me?" (something she never asked the murderer).

The remake goes into more detail as to why the man commits his murders, and David Wayne's big confession scene in the garage (a perfect update of Lang's subterranean mock trial) is both compelling in terms of his gut wrenching performance as well as psychologically sound (or maybe I should say "PSYCHO-logically"). In this regard, I think the remake improves on the original.

I am a big fan of Frtiz Lang. His "M" has long been one of my favorite films. I avoided seeing the remake for years because I thought it might taint or spoil my feelings for the original. This has not been the case. My appreciation of the original has only been amplified by seeing how Lang's film and screenwriter Thea Von Harbou's original script, so universal in its moral perceptions of human behavior, effectively translated to another time and place in such fine and expanded form.

The remake was made only 30 years after the original, so it could be that in 1951 Lang's film was still too revered to allow for an upstart low budget Hollywood remake to take any credit for itself. However, I think it's not too far fetched to imagine someone having not seen the original, stumbling upon the remake and considering it an American classic. Now that the original "M" is 75 years old, we have nothing to fear by appreciating Losey's remake for the good film it is, classic or not.

I'll add that it contains some great LA locations, Angel's Flight, the Bradbury Building, Bunker Hill, the 2nd Avenue Tunnel, etc., etc.
Some screen caps:

Angels Flight


Howard Da Silva


Glenn Anders


Raymond Burr


David Wayne


2nd St. Tunnel and the chase.


The shoeshine man points M out


The Bradbury Building


Wayne "M" caught in a mannequin storage room.


Great film needs a proper DVD release7/10

[dave jenkins]

I'd like to see this film, but those screen caps look like mush, and if they're a true indication of what the DVD-r is like, I guess I'll wait until something better comes along. (Thanks for posting them, though).

[titoli]

The mannequin storage room inspiration for analogue scene in Killer's Kiss?

[cigar joe]

Possibly but its not emphasized.

I'd like to see this film, but those screen caps look like mush, and if they're a true indication of what the DVD-r is like, I guess I'll wait until something better comes along. (Thanks for posting them, though).

The DVDr is slightly better, its the frame capture function that messes with the contrast on the frame for some reason.

I uploaded the opening here with the video capture on the same KMP program:

http://youtu.be/IovfalMQ6lQ

[Novecento]

I'd like to see this film, but those screen caps look like mush, and if they're a true indication of what the DVD-r is like, I guess I'll wait until something better comes along. (Thanks for posting them, though).

There is a Brazilian DVD release which I haven't watched myself:

http://www.submarino.com.br/produto/6/23793361/dvd+m+-+cine+cult