The Sergio Leone Elimination Game (ALL MEMBERS PARTICIPATE!)

[moviesceleton]

So, we can vote more than once? If that's the case:

A Fistfull of Dollars 6 (-1)
For a Few Dollars More 11
The Good, The Bad, and The Ugly 12 (+1)   
Once Upon a Time in the West 12
Duck, You Sucker 11
Once Upon a Time in America 8

If we're not allowed to vote more than once, the real situation is not what it shows here. TB, correct it if you will. But if we're not allowed to vote more than once, it's quite possible that this game is never going to end since there are not enough users on this forum.

[Jill]

A Fistfull of Dollars 6 (-1)
For a Few Dollars More 11
The Good, The Bad, and The Ugly 12 (+1)   
Once Upon a Time in the West 12
Duck, You Sucker 11
Once Upon a Time in America 8

No, it's not my favourite, I just could not watch it so underrated... 
Vol. 2:

A Fistfull of Dollars 6
For a Few Dollars More 11
The Good, The Bad, and The Ugly 12 
Once Upon a Time in the West 13 (+1)
Duck, You Sucker 11
Once Upon a Time in America 7 (-1)

[moviesceleton]

You like it more than OUATIA? 

[Tucumcari Bound]

So, we can vote more than once? If that's the case:

A Fistfull of Dollars 6 (-1)
For a Few Dollars More 11
The Good, The Bad, and The Ugly 12 (+1)   
Once Upon a Time in the West 12
Duck, You Sucker 11
Once Upon a Time in America 8

If we're not allowed to vote more than once, the real situation is not what it shows here. TB, correct it if you will. But if we're not allowed to vote more than once, it's quite possible that this game is never going to end since there are not enough users on this forum.

You're right moviesceleton, we may not be able to finish it. You're only supposed to vote once. We get tons of guest users all the time. I dunno why they never post.

[Jill]

You like it more than OUATIA? 

OUTIA is my less favorite. The heroes are just not so lovable... Noodles is very good (and I'm a Robert De Niro fan), but have no interesting in the others. I like it, but.. I think it's the matter that the first gangster movie I saw was The Godfather.  Like the first real grand western for me was OUTITW - very few others are as good as it. Only Sergio's and a few of Sam's works... 
So, OUTIA is good, but not his best, I think.

[Tucumcari Bound]

Once Upon a Time in America is flipping genius.

[moviesceleton]

You're right moviesceleton, we may not be able to finish it. You're only supposed to vote once. We get tons of guest users all the time. I dunno why they never post.

So you're accepting re-voting?

[Tucumcari Bound]

So you're accepting re-voting?

I dunno if re-voting makes much sense. What do you think?

[moviesceleton]

You're right, it doesn't make much sense if there are just a few members posting in, always the same votes. It would only cause sawing movement (as already seen  ). But on the other hand... this is never going to end, or at least it is going to take years.

[Tucumcari Bound]

You're right, it doesn't make much sense if there are just a few members posting in, always the same votes. It would only cause sawing movement (as already seen  ). But on the other hand... this is never going to end, or at least it is going to take years.

We'll just keep it up. Don't vote more than once. In do time, maybe it'll finish. haha

[Jill]

It's a great movie of course. Sergio did it, what else could it be?  Only I like westerns better. 
I think I should re-watch it...

[sb4]

I think I should re-watch it...

I find that I appreciate and enjoy it much more now (after several viewings) than when I first saw it.  It's so...dense, with so many shifts in tense, etc...not to mention some downright repellant behavior by certain major characters, etc. that it took me a while to come to terms with it, frankly.  But nowadays I definitely think of it as a masterpiece...an ugly story, beautifully told.

 

   
 

[geoman-1]

What the heck is going on here? I thought everyone would participate in this. 

It's probably the Holiday, TB.

[geoman-1]

Anyway,

FOD 5 (-1)
FFDM 11
TGBU 12
OUATITW 13
DYS 12 (+1)
OUATIA 7

BTW, pretty neat game TB

[Tucumcari Bound]

Anyway,

FOD 5 (-1)
FFDM 11
TGBU 12
OUATITW 13
DYS 12 (+1)
OUATIA 7

BTW, pretty neat game TB

Thanks geoman! I knew you all would like it. I just hope we can finish it. It's pretty fun.