The Sergio Leone Elimination Game (ALL MEMBERS PARTICIPATE!)

[Tucumcari Bound]

Gee, nobody is taking things personal here. We're just having a conversation about it. We're all friends here. It's ok to state your opinion. I like this game. It brings all of us members together to chat about Leone's films with something like this. Nobody is taking things personal, at least I'm not.

[geoman-1]

FFDM  6 (-1)
TGBU 13
OUATITW 21
DYS 14 (+1)
OUATIA 6

[Tucumcari Bound]

Updated List

For a Few Dollars More 6
The Good, The Bad and The Ugly 13
Once Upon a Time in the West 21
Duck, You Sucker 14
Once Upon a Time in America 6

Films Eliminated

A Fistful of Dollars

[Kurug3n]

Updated List

For a Few Dollars More 6
The Good, The Bad and The Ugly 13
Once Upon a Time in the West 21
Duck, You Sucker 14
Once Upon a Time in America 6

Films Eliminated

A Fistful of Dollars

FAFDM- 7 (+1)
DYS- 13 (-1)

[The Peacemaker]

FAFDM- 7 (+1)
DYS- 13 (-1)

        


SHOOT YOURSELF!

[Kurug3n]

        


SHOOT YOURSELF!

 

I stand by it because even though DYS is a great film. I like FAFDM because of the dark plot thats in it.

[The Peacemaker]

DYS is way darker!


That's like comparing night to a shadow!

[Tucumcari Bound]

DYS is way darker!


That's like comparing night to a shadow!

I'll have to agree with Peacemaker here kurug3n. Duck, You Sucker is Leone's darkest film, easily.

[Tucumcari Bound]

Updated List

For a Few Dollars More 7
The Good, The Bad and The Ugly 13
Once Upon a Time in the West 21
Duck, You Sucker 13
Once Upon a Time in America 6

Films Eliminated

A Fistful of Dollars


***REMEMBER*** Once a film has been eliminated, you can then vote once again. But only once until the next film is gone.

[Kurug3n]

I'll have to agree with Peacemaker here kurug3n. Duck, You Sucker is Leone's darkest film, easily.

Its a revolution bad sh*t is always going to happen but a psycho drug-induced criminal that actually killed  for the hell of it and not really gain anything in the process seems to be a more darker character to me and that is why i like FAFDM better.

[Tucumcari Bound]

Its a revolution bad sh*t is always going to happen but a psycho drug-induced criminal that actually killed  for the hell of it and not really gain anything in the process seems to be a more darker character to me and that is why i like FAFDM better.

Hey kurug3n you make valid points buddy. I respect your opinion totally. For a Few Dollars More is a dark film, I'm not doubting that. Duck, You Sucker though we see hundreds of innocent people being murdered in cold blood, far more drastic than we see in For a Few Dollars More. I'm not saying I'm right, it's just my opinion.

[Kurug3n]

Hey kurug3n you make valid points buddy. I respect your opinion totally. For a Few Dollars More is a dark film, I'm not doubting that. Duck, You Sucker though we see hundreds of innocent people being murdered in cold blood, far more drastic than we see in For a Few Dollars More. I'm not saying I'm right, it's just my opinion.

I agree but i just like FAFDM better. I guess because Van Cleef and Volonte just bring out some kick ass performances.

[Tucumcari Bound]

I agree but i just like FAFDM better. I guess because Van Cleef and Volonte just bring out some kick ass performances.

I have no problems with your vote. There's absolutely nothing wrong with it. FAFDM is a brilliant film and it's the first time Leone set out to make an EPIC and he succeeded! FAFDM is not only one of the greatest westerns ever made, but films in general in my opinion.

[Rojo Ramone]

With my last post I didn't mean to imply that this isn't an interesting game~because it is...I can't wait to jump in and vote again.

[Tucumcari Bound]

With my last post I didn't mean to imply that this isn't an interesting game~because it is...I can't wait to jump in and vote again.

Oh, no worries Rojo! I can't wait to vote again myself. There's still a lot of members that come on here and there and don't vote. This could be going a lot faster than it is so IF ANYBODY IS READING THIS AND HAS NOT VOTED YET, PLEASE DO SO! Thanks friends. 

Cannot access offset of type string on string