Song to Song 3/10WOW.
McCabe & Mrs Miller 6.5/10I finally got around to see this weird one. Fresh take on the genre, I really like where they went with it. I'm among the ones who think the Cohen songs add a lot to the film's whimsical mood (in a good way). The best thing it has going for it, and that will inspire filmmakers at some point, is the way the environment is a character of its own, evolving with the story. And of course the great "physicality" of such a set (I'm sure these things will come back, one way or another, at some point in the near future).The fake snow during the shootout really took me outside of the film. Anyway, the film is a bit rough for a first viewing (I understand why CJ was initially so caution when writing about it in the film's thread), so I could see its charm but not feel it that much. I'll probably rethink my rating after a second viewing some day: it's the kind of film that either grows on you or becomes annoying as hell.Of course, like many here have noted, its influence on OUATIA is striking.
Your rating is too low. Yeah, I know, for you 6.5/10 means “great movie”
What’s the influence on OUATIA?
McCabe & Mrs Miller 6.5/10The fake snow during the shootout really took me outside of the film.
SPOILERSeveral things, including similarities in the Max/Miller vs Noodles/McCabe opposition. But the most obvious one to me is the Chinese opium den with zoom in in the end... under similar circumstances. There is a lot of discussion about it in the film's thread.
I take it you mean the fake snowfall, as the snow on the ground is the real deal. But you're absolutely right. On re-watches it really annoys me too. Still, even with those blemishes, I enjoy the last half-hour of the film a tremendous amount.
I let it slide. I still think it would make a good miniseries along the lines of Deadwood.