Cannes 2017

[Novecento]

Yet some of the festival's experiments have already proven highly combustible. After an outcry from French theaters, organizers announced last week that beginning next year, films without the intentions of a theatrical release in France won't be eligible for Cannes' prestigious Palme d'Or competition - the festival's main slate of about 20 films.

I can see where the Cannes festival is coming from with this. It's Cinema Paradiso versus binge watching.

The move effectively bars Netflix releases from Europe's answer to an Oscar race.

"Europe's answer..."  Last time I checked, the Cannes film festival went back a little further in time than the founding of the EU. I think "version" rather than "answer" would be a better choice of words here.

[drinkanddestroy]

"Europe's answer..."  Last time I checked, the Cannes film festival went back a little further in time than the founding of the EU. I think "version" rather than "answer" would be a better choice of words here.

How can you compare the Oscars, in which all (American) films compete, and a festival in which only 20 films compete?

[Novecento]

How do you mean? Aren't the films with a chance of winning a Best Picture Oscar (currently set at 10) and those with a chance of winning a Palme D'Or (set at 20) all pre-selected regardless?

[drinkanddestroy]

How do you mean? Aren't the films with a chance of winning a Best Picture Oscar (currently set at 10) and those with a chance of winning a Palme D'Or (set at 20) all pre-selected regardless?

point is, not every film premieres at Cannes. There are many great films that never premiere at Cannes and therefore are ineligible for the Palme d'ore. Every movie is eligible for Oscar contention.

[drinkanddestroy]

Clint Eastwood at Cannes for 25th anniversary of Unforgiven

http://hosted.ap.org/dynamic/stories/E/EU_FRANCE_CANNES_CLINT_EASTWOOD?SITE=AP&SECTION=HOME&TEMPLATE=DEFAULT

[Novecento]

point is, not every film premieres at Cannes. There are many great films that never premiere at Cannes and therefore are ineligible for the Palme d'ore. Every movie is eligible for Oscar contention.

Every movie is eligible for Cannes. You just need to submit it and then cross your fingers. Of course if you choose to show it somewhere else first then you miss your opportunity, but that's your choice.

[Milan NS]

Looking forward to Polanski's new film.

[stanton]

Looking forward to Polanski's new film.

Really?

He was great in the 60s, and in the 70s he made his best film Chinatown, but the others were already not that interesting in this decade, and since then his films are not very interesting for me. Then, suddenly, his last one was a positive surprise. But I still don't expect anything from him.

[Novecento]

Really?

Yes, really.

His last big-budget release "The Ghost", which was horribly renamed "The Ghost Writer" in North America, was absolutely fantastic ("Carnage" and "Venus in Fur" were much smaller scale affairs).

[stanton]

Yes, really.

His last big-budget release "The Ghost", which was horribly renamed "The Ghost Writer" in North America, was absolutely fantastic ("Carnage" and "Venus in Fur" were much smaller scale affairs).

Wasn't Ghost Writer the original title?

It was good, but nothing special (maybe 7/10), and Carnage was comparatively awful (4/10), and Venus in Furs the big surprise (8,5/10)

[Novecento]

Wasn't Ghost Writer the original title?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Ghost_(Harris_novel)

It was stylish and very atmospheric. I haven't read the novel, but the conversion into a screenplay was deftly handled.

[stanton]

The The Ghost is the book title, The Ghost Writer is the film's original title.

Can't remember that much style.

[Novecento]

It had the original title in the UK release:

[stanton]

But in France and in Germany, the other co-producer countries, it was The Ghost Writer, and that is everywhere cited as the original title.

It seems the Brits changed it to correspondent with the book.

[Novecento]

But in France and in Germany, the other co-producer countries, it was The Ghost Writer, and that is everywhere cited as the original title.

It seems the Brits changed it to correspondent with the book.

I would argue that the working title of "The Ghost" was changed for release in other English-speaking regions through another unfortunate case of dumbing down that destroyed the ambiguity of the original title. Perhaps it was only kept in the UK due to the popularity of the original book there? Translations into other languages aren't really valid since rarely do words match 100% across different languages however closely related, although I would note that some other countries (e.g. Denmark, Russia, Lithuania) went with a straight translation of "The Ghost" too according to IMDb.