Judging from it's trailer, a line spoken by Christopher Plummer provides the key to the film's concernes: "I beg of you, let not America go wrong in her first hour."http://www.thenewworldmovie.com/
Casting Pocahontas as a very young girl would be difficult for the following two reasons. The actress has to age convincingly between 1607, the year she saves Smith, and 1614, the year she marries Rolfe. Also, casting an underage performer in a sexual role will always be big trouble when it comes to censorship pressures and general critical reception. As it is, Malick has cast a 15 year old, I'll be curious to see if any "ban this filth" tabloid nonsese bursts out when the film is released.
I'm in the "Love It" camp. You're right, it's a beautiful movie. It takes a little while to get going, but once you get sucked in there's no turning back. The most pleasant surprise in TNW was Colin Farrell who gave a really good performance as John Smith. I think my favorite part may be the end (no, not like that ) with all the different shots of nature with the musical score playing. A very moving picture overall. I might have to buy this one now, thanks TB!
It's a bluddy masterpiece. I left my tuppence worth here:http://www.fistful-of-leone.com/forums/index.php?topic=2628.0The last time I saw it I had something of a "religious experience". I saw it on a giant screen in a cinema beside the Thames in London, with a perfect sound system. As I staggered out onto the Embankment on a lovely summers evening, the sun was setting on the water, turning it into a blinding mirror, the same river she had travelled on, and sailed down to Gravesend and her death. The vision turned me to mush.