There's really no need for you to go fishing for compliments like this. I'm sure you understood very well what I meant.
The party scene is insipid. And this is particularly damning when you recollect there's an equally bad party scene in Darling.The film impressed me when I was 17, but now I consign it to that limbo in which Catcher in the Rye and A Separate Peace and Of Mice and Men and other such works float about. I shall never watch it again.
Gorgeous cinematography? Looked very cheap to me. Apart from that, you spot most of the flaws of that film, while forgetting the main one: it's boring to death. I still cannot put anything lower than 5 since... there is not much to really criticize either.
Che: Part One - 5-6/10 - I have finally gotten around to seeing this (thank you, Netflix!) and I have pretty mixed feelings. I have any number of problems with the film. The biggest one being that, for a movie about such a controversial and colorful character, it's really rather dull. There's little narrative flow, next to zero characterization, preventing much tangible entertainment value. The film finesses any political controversy by completely ignoring politics altogether: the film does not openly endorse nor condemn Che (I will say it tacitly supports him), but it's so bland that you can't claim "objectivity" either. Aside from some bald platitudes we don't get any sense of Che and Castro's politics, nor the Batista regime's cruelty; the film shows (correctly) that Batista's men had little stomach for fighting, so one might ask why the Revolution was so difficult? Throw in a useless framing device and narration and you've got a film full of problems. Good acting, gorgeous cinematography and a few set-pieces that really shine (particularly the Siege of Santa Clara), so it's not a total loss. Hopefully Part II will be better.
Che Part Two - 5/10 - The first fifteen minutes feature an animated geography lesson, a shot of a television set, and a bald guy we never see again puttering around and cleaning his dentures at length. It gets marginally better after that.